Overcoming the tyranny of Power Point and using its advantages

When I attend presentations when people use Power Point, nine times out of ten, the speaker reads the print or figures on each projected slide aloud, pointing to some items with a red beam of light to remind those of us in the audience what item is being read aloud. The font in the slides is often too small for those of us in the audience to see if we sit beyond the 6th row. But this does not matter because if there are fewer than 50 of us we are given a printed copy of each slide. So we can read the print even in a small font since we have it before our eyes.

 

What I do and notice others doing is reading the printed slides in front of us. Since we can read silently at least twice as fast as the person reading aloud, we often close our ears and focus our eyes.

 

Why these practices are so widespread I would like any of you who are keen on these practices to tell me.

Even some who follow these practices are not able to tell me why they follow these steps except to say, “everyone does.”

 

If you are fine with these usual steps, stop reading. If you would like to consider some alternatives, here are a few.

 

Alternative I

  1. Good morning. Pls. read the first 3 slides on the handout and write a question or comment you have about them.
  2. Discuss the comments and respond to the questions and ask participants to respond to questions from others in the audience.
  3. Pls. read the next 3 slides, or 4 or whatever number deal with one point.
  4. Repeat step 2.

 

In short, use the texts as an impetus to discuss the points you are making rather than just talking at people and then at the end say “Oh, we have a few minutes left if you want to ask any questions.”

 

Alternative II

 

I have attached some remarks I made at an opening ceremony at a college I was president of in NZ. The ceremony was held in a theater that seated around 500 people. New students, present students, faculty, parents of students and members of the community were attending.

 

There was a large screen on the stage where I was standing so that the 10 pictures at the bottom of the page, which I showed one by one as I mentioned them, were easily seen by all 500 in the audience. The projected pictures were like 20 feet square! As I mentioned each picture I pointed to features that I was talking about using the red beam so loved by those who use Power Point. The pictures were in color when I projected them. In the jpg on page 4, as part of this Blog, they are black and white as you can see.

 

I had not given out a printed copy of my comments so some in the audience missed many of my comments. But since my questions were similar, just to ask participants to wonder, they in fact did wonder.

 

And when I took off my suit jacket, tie and dress shirt, though I said many words they were not needed as the people could see what I was doing.

Having said this, since many in the audience were not strong speakers of English, they could connect what I said with my actions and the pictures so they could get more than if I had just shown what I was saying in Power Point.

 

When you get to PDF 3 on page 5 you will see that the copy is not perfectly clear so you will have to figure out the numbers on the clock that are in reverse order and you cannot see the message on my t-shirt since the message is on the back of the t-shirt and the picture of the universe is on the front.

 

Oh, by the way, the Governor General in NZ is the representative of the queen. But NZ, to generalize, is a very egalitarian society so the GG was not at all taken aback by my taking off my jacket, tie and dress shirt.

 

Enjoy, enjoy.

 

John

 

 

PS Consider using Power Point in a playful way rather than as a kind of straightjacket. Projecting pictures with Power Point can engage participants a great deal. In the past we had to use overhead projectors or slide projectors. PP is an advance. Why not try not take advantage of this a re using visuals. Why not take advantage of the advantage of this advance?

 

 

 

 

 

C 2001 Like a child 3

2 Replies to “Overcoming the tyranny of Power Point and using its advantages”

  1. John, I offer a counterview on this practice that I have learned to really appreciate. A lot of time when I listen to speakers at research conferences, I find their speech quite intelligible. I am relieved when they read from their slides which we can see. That’s because I get to jot down notes that might be useful for me in my next research project. If I don’t see the slides, I’d lose the opportunity to note its possible relevance to my future endeavor. True, I can read it online but that’s would be after the event, not right there in the hall.

    1. Dear Ken,

      I love counter views. But what if you were given a printed version of the slides to read and re read and then engaged in discussions with both the person presenting and other participants? Being right in the hall, your last comment, I resonate with. It is more engaging to see and hear a person rather than just read on line. But if you have printed copies of what the person is presenting and then can discuss with the person it might be richer? Look forward to your reflections.

      john

Leave a Reply to Ken Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *